Critical Podium Dewanand Islam
Muslim Brothers of Indian Subcontinent: It's Time
for Homecoming, Part II by Dr Radhasyam Brahmachari
Sacrificer Dr Radhasyam Brahmachari
Sacrifice code wfor0441
Sacrifice date 09 Sep, 2008
Muslim Brothers of Indian Subcontinent: It's Time for Homecoming, Part
by Dr Radhasyam Brahmachari
09 Sep, 2008
Editor note: We are in favor of leaving religions altogether. However,
this article is published here, because, a peaceful appeal to Muslims
for their return to their roots, from which they were brutalized to accept
Islam, deserves a place here and everywhere else.
Islamic God Allah
Muslim intellectuals try to convince that by embracing Islam they are
following monotheism, which is far superior to polytheism of Hinduism.
According to them, Islam is the only religion that is strictly monotheistic,
as its followers worship only one God Allah. But it seems, from Koran
and other Islamic scriptures, that Allah is not confident that he is the
only God in the world (not in the universe as Allah is aware only about
heaven and earth).
Had Allah been the only God, it would not have been possible for man
to find another God to worship.. And had Allah been confident that there
is no other God except him, he should not have been jealous of another
God. For example, let us imagine a village where there is only one well
as the source of fresh water. Hence there would not have been any difference
whether the villagers drink water from a glass or from a pitcher, or from
a jug. And as there is not an alternative source, it must have been derived
from that lone well. In a similar manner, if Allah knew that there is
no other God, he would have been confident that people will not find another
God to worship.
But the behavioral pattern of Allah suggests that he is not confident
that he is the only God. He seems always to be suspicious that there may
be other Gods and people may worship those Gods instead of him and thus
they may create a partner to him. So the scared Allah warns man not to
worship another God or create a partner to him and says,
"Say, 'people of the Book, let us come to an agreement: that we
will worship none but Allah, that we will associate none with Him, and
that none of us shall set up mortals as deities besides Allah" [Qurab
3:64, tr: N J Dawood, the word 'God' replaced by 'Allah', because, according
to Dr Zakir Naik, 'God' is not a true translation of 'Allah'].
In this context, it should be mentioned here that, as the Hindu God is
confident that He is the only God in this universe, He does not become
jealous of another God. Bhagavadgitâ 9: 23 says,
"O Kaunteya (Arjuna), even those who worship other gods with devotion
(bhakti), they do really worship Me, though the rite differ from the norm"
(tr: R C Zaehner).
The Hindu God does not become angry and say, "you have committed
the foulest sin by worshiping other gods or associating partner (shirk)
with Me and I shall throw you in hell fire as a punishment for this sin,
because He is confident that He is the only God, and no one could find
another God to worship.
To speak the truth, Allah is not a god at all. Allah is a cruel tyrant,
a brutal killer and a violent despot. Evidently, the Islamic Umma has
excelled the rest of humanity in criminality on earth. Their criminal
behavior is fostered by Allah's violent teachings for establishing Himself
as the sole God of the world (not of the universe). Allah is always scared
that a member of his Muslim gang may slip out of his grip and start to
worship another God, probably the real creator of the universe. So he
has enforced strict law that if any one of his gang tries to desert Him,
he should immediately be put to death for apostasy. This is similar to
standing rule of underworld criminal gangs. If a member of the gang leaves
it, even with the intention of leading a decent life, the other members
of the gang murder him instantly fearing that he may disclose their secrets.
Though the Muslim clerics treacherously portray Hinduism as a polytheist
religion, only to highlight the crude and false monotheism of Islam, Hinduism
is the oldest monotheistic religion in the world. Hinduism may appear
to a commoner to be a polytheistic creed with many deities. But at its
heart, Hinduism is absolutely monotheistic. In Hinduism, God (or Îshvara)
is one, but deities are many.. The deities are only the manifestations
of the one supreme God (Ishvara or Brahma). The Rigveda says,
· God is one but people call Him by many names
like Agni, yama, Matariúva etc. [RV 1/164/46]
· With fair wings though there is only One (bird),
sages imagine many [RV 10/114/5]
So, when Muslim clerics describe Hinduism as a polytheistic religion
and ridicule Hindus for worshiping many Gods, they display their utter
ignorance about even the basic ideas of Hinduism. While commenting on
this aspect of Hinduism, Abdul Aziz al-Aman, a renowned Bengali author
and publisher, writes, "The doctrine of monotheism is much deeper
and pervasive in the philosophy of the Upanisads
So, there is no
doubt that, before the revelation of the Koran, monotheism had been well
established in Vedas in India " (Preface of the Koran, tr. by Girish
According to Muslim scholars, Allah is best defined by 4 verses of the
112th Sura (Sura Ekhlas) of the Holy Koran that says, "Say; Allah
is one, the eternal Allah. He begot none, nor was He begotten.. None is
equal to Him" [tr: N J Dawood].
Let us investigate the real nature of Allah as narrated in the Koran and
reliable Hadith. Islamic scriptures cannot say what Allah was doing before
he created this heaven and earth. However, a hadith throws some light
on it and says, "I asked the Prophet, 'Where was Allah before His
creation?' Muhammad replied: 'He was in a cloud with no air underneath
or above it" (Tabari I:204 ). But the question remains: Who created
those clouds in which Allah took shelter, before Allah had begun his creation?
As Muslims do not worship the idol of Allah, many believe that Islamic
Allah is formless. But the notion is entirely wrong. Islamic Allah has
a physical body, which is 60 cubit tall (Shahih Muslim 6809). Furthermore,
Allah's appearance is like a human being, as Allah created Adam in his
own image (SM 2872). Another Hadith (SM 6325) says that a Muslim, during
a conflict, should not deface another Muslim, as Allah has created every
human face like that of his own. This Hadith confirms the notion that
the physical appearance of Allah is more or less like human beings, but
he is 60 cubits tall and, perhaps, he remains invisible to man. Quran
6:101 says that Allah does not have a wife; this confirms that Allah is
almost a male human being, but he has extraordinary miraculous power (qudrah).
Moreover, Allah is a sexually capable man.
During the life-time of Prophet Muhammad, a debate arose between the
Jews and the Christians of Medina, where the Prophet himself was present.
In that debate, the Jews were refuting the claim of Christians that Jesus
was the son of Allah. The Jews ridiculed the Christians and said, "Did
Allah sleep with Maryam?" This could have been a basis for the Christians
to establish their claim. But the Prophet was not ready to admit the same
as in that case Allah could have been convicted of committing adultery
as Maryam was already married. At last, the Prophet could settle the dispute
by saying that, as Allah had created Adam from clay by his extraordinary
miraculous power (qudrah), in a similar manner, Allah created Jesus in
Maryam's womb with his qudrah. The incident confirms beyond all doubt
that Islamic Allah is almost a male human being capable of procreating
a baby in the womb of a woman by sexual intercourse. [The incident has
been narrated in KABAR PATHEY (On the Road to Kabaa),Vol. 2, p. 190) by
the reputed Bengali author Abdul Aziz al Aman]. One may note here that,
though Allah is a male human being, his masculinity has ever remained
unused, as he has no spouse and he does not commit adultery with any other
woman. So, it becomes evident that, though Allah is a sexually capable
masculine, his masculinity has never been put to use.
In this context, it is important to note that, in one of his lectures
on the Similarities Between Hinduism and Islam, Dr Naik tells a naked
lie that the Quranic Allah is 'genderless'. But we have seen above that,
Islamic Allah is almost a male human being. However, the present author
cannot read Arabic and hence he is unable to say what is written in Arabic
Koran. But in all its English translations, the authors have mentioned
Allah as "He". Had Allah been projected genderless in Arabic
Koran, they would have used the word "It", instead of "He".
In addition to a 60-cubit tall physical body, Allah has human attributes
like vengeance, envy, cruelty and so on. Due to his enviousness, Allah
becomes violently angry when a man worships any other God besides Him.
He punishes such sinners with grievous punishment (azab), either in this
world or with hell-fire in the next life. Moreover, Allah is highly biased
or discriminative. He is most merciful (Rahmanir-rahim) only to Muslims,
but a cruel despot, a ferocious demon, to non-Muslims. A imagined god
with such humanly body and attributes is incapable of withstanding the
onslaught of time, cannot be eternal. Such a deity is bound to age and
ultimately perish all humans.
For rest of the article log on to:
Critical Podium Dewanand Islam
All rights reserved.